Great
The entire trip was absolutely amazing, but I wouldn't recommend the VIP option. You get the same as everyone else plus lobster (which was quite nice) and a glass of wine (which wasn't). I had to ask for the wine after not getting served for 20 minutes. A bit of a rip off really. Otherwise our tour guide was great, the catamaran and glass bottom boat were good fun, the island and sea was beautiful, the drinks were plentiful. Didn't see any starfish, but hey ho, that's nature.